The NFL's Leftovers: Why Rodgers and Samuel Are Still Kicking Around
It’s late February, the Super Bowl confetti is swept up, and most of the big free-agent fish have already been reeled in. But a few whales are still out there, swimming in the open market, and their situations are getting more interesting by the day. We're not talking about fringe players; we're talking about guys who can still move the needle.
The Quarterback Conundrum: Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers. The name alone conjures images of MVP trophies and last-second heroics. He’s 40 now, coming off a torn Achilles that ended his 2023 season after just four snaps. That’s the big asterisk. Before the injury, he signed a three-year, $112 million deal with the Jets last March. New York gave up a first-round pick, a second-rounder, and more for him. Now? His future is murky. He’s technically under contract for 2024 with a hefty $35 million guaranteed. But the Jets could be looking to shed that if he retires or if they find another option.
Here’s the thing: Rodgers isn't going to play for a bottom-feeder. He wants a contender, or at least a team with a clear path to one. The Jets still have a decent roster, but their offensive line was a sieve last year, giving up 64 sacks, second-most in the league. If Rodgers decides he's done with New York, a dark horse like the Minnesota Vikings could make a play if Kirk Cousins leaves. Imagine Rodgers throwing to Justin Jefferson. That’s a Super Bowl-caliber offense right there, even with Rodgers at 40.
Deebo Samuel's Market Value
Deebo Samuel is another fascinating case. He’s a dynamic playmaker, a true Swiss Army knife for the 49ers. In 2021, he exploded for 1,405 receiving yards and 8 total touchdowns, earning first-team All-Pro honors. He’s under contract with San Francisco through 2025, with a base salary of $20.9 million in 2024. So why is he on this list? Trade rumors. They’ve been swirling since before the 2023 season, fueled by the 49ers' deep receiver room and Samuel's past contract disputes.
The 49ers have George Kittle, Brandon Aiyuk, and Christian McCaffrey all demanding touches. Samuel's production dipped slightly in 2023, with 892 receiving yards and 7 touchdowns, but he still averaged 14.9 yards per reception. He’s a tough runner after the catch, breaking 12 tackles last season. Teams like the Baltimore Ravens, who desperately need another elite pass-catcher to pair with Mark Andrews, or even the Carolina Panthers, looking for a veteran presence for Bryce Young, could be in the mix. The cost would be high, likely a second-round pick and change, but Samuel's versatility is worth it for a team ready to compete. I think the 49ers finally pull the trigger and trade him this offseason. They need the cap space and draft capital more than they need three elite receivers.
Other Intriguing Names
Beyond the big two, there are other players who could still make an impact. Dalvin Cook, the former Vikings running back, is still looking for a home. He rushed for over 1,100 yards four straight seasons from 2019-2022. His short stint with the Jets in 2023 didn't pan out, but he’s still only 28. A team needing a veteran presence and a reliable third-down back could take a flier. Think the Dallas Cowboys if Tony Pollard walks, or even the New Orleans Saints.
Then there's Calais Campbell. The 37-year-old defensive end proved he still has gas in the tank with 6.5 sacks for the Falcons in 2023. He’s a locker room leader and a rotational pass rusher who could help a contender. The Detroit Lions, fresh off a deep playoff run, could use his experience and pass-rushing prowess.
Bold prediction: Aaron Rodgers, despite all the noise, plays another season for the New York Jets and leads them to the AFC Championship game.