Updated March 16, 2026
| 1 | Joao Palhinha Bayern (prev Fulham) | 11 yellows 28 apps |
| 2 | Rodrigo Bentancur Tottenham | 10 yellows 24 apps |
| 3 | Declan Rice Arsenal | 9 yellows 28 apps |
| 4 | Casemiro Man United | 9 yellows 22 apps |
| 5 | Douglas Luiz Juventus (prev Villa) | 8 yellows 20 apps |
| 6 | James Ward-Prowse West Ham | 8 yellows 27 apps |
| 7 | Yves Bissouma Tottenham | 8 yellows 25 apps |
| 8 | Lewis Dunk Brighton | 7 yellows 26 apps |